Skip to content

Matthew 10:28

False Teaching of Annihilationism

layers Part 7 of 10 menu_book More on Matthew lightbulb 8 illustrations in this sermon

Pastor Martin refutes the false teaching of annihilationism, which claims that impenitent sinners will eventually cease to exist rather than endure eternal conscious punishment. He systematically dismantles the four main arguments of annihilationists: their view of man's nature, their interpretation of key biblical words like 'perish' and 'destroy,' their understanding of hell's purpose, and their concept of Christ's redemptive scope. Martin then outlines the severe theological, personal, and ministerial consequences of denying eternal punishment, emphasizing that this doctrine is central to understanding God's wrath, appreciating salvation, and motivating evangelism and faithful preaching.

Primary Texts

menu_book
Matthew 10:28 This verse is central to refuting annihilationism by demonstrating the soul's survival and God's power to destroy both soul and body in hell, implying conscious punishment.
menu_book
Luke 16 The parable of the rich man and Lazarus is used to explicitly illustrate conscious torment and the soul's existence after physical death, directly contradicting annihilationist claims.
menu_book
Matthew 25:46 This passage directly contrasts 'everlasting life' with 'everlasting punishment,' establishing the eternal duration of both states and refuting the idea of cessation of existence for the wicked.

Outline 11 sections · 45 min

  1. The Neglected Doctrine of Everlasting Punishment and Christ's Teaching on Hell 0:03
  2. Two Avenues of Denying Eternal Punishment: Universalism and Annihilationism 4:39
  3. Defining Annihilationism and its Distortion of Scripture 7:33
  4. The Four Supposed Scriptural Bases of Annihilationism 9:04
  5. Refuting Annihilationism: The Biblical Nature of Man 15:49
  6. Refuting Annihilationism: The Meaning of Key Words 20:33
  7. Refuting Annihilationism: The Purpose of Hell and Scope of Christ's Work 24:18
  8. The Subtle Deception of Annihilationism 25:43
  9. Theological Results of Denying Eternal Punishment 28:27
  10. Personal Results of Denying Eternal Punishment 32:35
  11. Ministerial Results and Final Exhortation 37:44

Key Quotes

“Either we embrace the Christ of scripture and his hell, or we reject the hell of scripture and along with it reject the Christ of scripture and go out and make our own Christ.”
“And we may say reverently, this is the hell of hells. It's eternity.”
“And that's the core of the issue, isn't it? When God threatens a terrible judgment upon the impenitent, He's not playing with words.”
“Listen, my friend, every attribute of God is an attribute stretched out to infinity. It is infinite love with which God loves. It is infinite mercy that he shows. And it's infinite wrath and judgment that he pours upon the head of the wicked.”
“Generally speaking, biblical views of grace and salvation centered in the work of Christ do not long live in any other soil but the soil of this doctrine of eternal punishment.”
“The less hell there is in the hearts of men and in the minds of men, the more hell there will be in their lives and in their society.”
“You've done something to your mind that you can play tricks with any other clearly taught doctrine in Holy Scripture.”
“Since when did I make you a judge over me to tell me what is just and right for me?”

Applications

All listeners

  • Repent and believe the Gospel to flee the wrath to come.
  • Fear God who can destroy both soul and body in hell, especially in the face of persecution.
  • Be motivated by the doctrine of eternal punishment to gratitude and stability in the face of opposition.
  • Do not play mental tricks with the words of Scripture or twist them to your own destruction.
  • Preach the whole counsel of God, including the doctrine of eternal punishment, without compromise or fear of man.
  • Teach the doctrine of hell tearfully, carefully, tenderly, and in the power of the Holy Spirit.
  • Repent and flee to Christ, casting yourself upon Him for forgiveness and salvation, trusting only in who He is and what He has done.
  • Evidence belief in this doctrine by tender, persistent, and careful dealings with men, and by earnest, fervent prayers on their behalf.
  • Allow the full motivating power of this doctrine to work in our lives, knowing the terror of the Lord to persuade men.

A full transcript is available on the tab. 116 paragraphs, roughly 45 minutes.

More from the archive