Skip to content

1 Corinthians 11:3

Objections to Sexual Identity, Part 4

layers Part 20 of 27 menu_book More on 1 Corinthians lightbulb 8 illustrations in this sermon

In "Objections to Sexual Identity, Part 4," Pastor Martin continues his series on male and female identity, roles, and functions, focusing on objections to male headship and female subordination arising from within the professing evangelical church. He refutes two main arguments: first, that biblical teaching on headship lacks permanent authority, exemplified by Paul K. Jewett's view that Paul's teaching was marred by rabbinical prejudice; and second, that while authoritative for the first century, these teachings are not timeless, but rather 'seed principles' that lead to the eventual abolition of gender distinctions, akin to the New Testament's treatment of slavery. Martin vigorously defends the inerrancy and sufficiency of Scripture, arguing that such objections undermine Christ's prophetic office and lead to a subjective interpretation of God's Word, ultimately leaving the church without a clear guide.

Primary Texts

menu_book
1 Corinthians 11:3 This verse is presented as the foundational text for understanding the divinely established hierarchy of headship, which the sermon defends against objections.
menu_book
1 Corinthians 14:37 This verse is expounded to directly refute the first objection, as Paul explicitly states his directives are 'the commandments of the Lord,' not merely his own prejudiced opinions.

Outline 8 sections · 49 min

  1. Introduction to the Series and Current Focus 0:05
  2. The Necessity of Refuting Objections and Disposing of the Pragmatic Argument 1:57
  3. Defining 'Evangelical' and Introducing Internal Objections 5:18
  4. Objection 1: Undermining the Permanent Authority of Biblical Teaching 9:38
  5. Refutation of Objection 1: Rejection of Biblical Authority and Christ's Prophetic Office 17:02
  6. Objection 2: Denying the Timeless Relevance of Biblical Teaching (The 'Seed Principle' Argument) 25:41
  7. Refutation of Objection 2: Attack on Scripture's Nature and Misuse of Cultural Adaptation 40:33
  8. Conclusion and Prayer Against Error 46:30

Key Quotes

“However, though the teaching is clear, it is not unopposed and universally accepted.”
“But I'm thinking particularly of those that would take to themselves the name evangelical.”
“What we have in these passages is Paul, the imperfectly sanctified saint...expressing a view of male and female roles and relationships that had been, as it were, pummeled into him in his rabbinical training.”
“You see, these people cherish Paul and Peter as inspired fallible penmen when it serves their cause, but when it does not serve their cause, they are prepared to call them poor, pathetic, perfectly unsanctified Christians, imperfectly sanctified Christians, whose prejudice mars their pronouncements.”
“He is prophet, priest, and king and if he is your redeemer he is your redeemer in the exercise of all three offices or he is not your redeemer at all.”
“What this does is it leaves the present church without a sufficient and adequate revelation of the mind and will of God for its life and practice it leaves us at the tyranny of the experts...”
“Slavery has never put in that context there is never any polemic for the order of slavery rooted in any divinely structured activity in creation or redemption so to bring in slavery as a parallel put loose and fancy free with the word of God...”
“Oh God to hate damning ideas help us to loathe them like we would the smell and the sight of an open sewer may we be able to say with the psalmist I esteem all your precepts concerning all things to be right therefore I every false way Lord we hate the false ways of Dr. Brunt bring them to naught blow upon the may the enemy of our souls not take advantage of even this much exposure of those thoughts ever to cause them to germinate in the heart of anyone in this place Lord as we subject our bodies to a mild dose of a disease that we might build up an immunity so may what we've heard today act like a good successful inoculation against all of these diseased thoughts of men we ask in Jesus name Amen”

Applications

All listeners

  • Elders must not only set forth positive biblical teaching but also refute gainsayers and protect the sheep from wolves.
  • Be aware of the subtle and convincing arguments against biblical teaching on gender roles that arise from within evangelical circles.
  • Feel a sense of shock and horror when the Word of God is treated with such disrespect and arbitrary rejection of authority.
  • Immediately recognize arguments that selectively accept or reject biblical authority as a blatant, arrogant insubordination to the Word of God.
  • Embrace Christ as Prophet, Priest, and King, understanding that refusing to embrace His prophetic word is as damning as refusing to trust His cross or bow to His crown.
  • Do not allow the church to be left without a sufficient and adequate revelation of God's will, subject to the tyranny of experts or societal pressures.
  • Hate damning ideas and loathe them like an open sewer, esteeming all God's precepts as right and hating every false way.
  • Pray for immunization against diseased thoughts and false teachings, so that exposure to error builds immunity rather than causing germination in the heart.

A full transcript is available on the tab. 46 paragraphs, roughly 49 minutes.

More from the archive